Are Shock Collars Humane?

Dog Training 101: Are Shock Collars Humane?

Thomas Barrington

Welcoming a dog into your family is one of life’s most exciting moments, but trying to find the right training guidance can be a daunting task. With so much conflicting advice on offer, it’s often difficult to decide on the best route forward for you and your furry friend.

Shock collars are a popular choice for dog training, but they’re also a topic of contention for animal rights activists. Many argue that these devices are inhumane and positive reinforcement is a safer alternative.

In this blog post, we’re going to explain why shock collars ARE humane, and show you the ins and outs of how they work to deliver effective training to your pup.

Keep reading to find out more!

What Is a Shock Training Collar Collar?

Initially used in the 1960s for hunting dogs, shock collars have provided obedience training to generations of canines. While it’s true that the earlier versions may have been too powerful, modern training collars are very mild and offer a perfectly humane solution.

Even with the most militant dog training routines, canines will behave undesirably at one point or another. Shock collars are often used to eliminate:

  • Nuisance barking, both in the day and night
  • Houdini-like hounds who escape the yard
  • Poor recall in public parks and spaces
  • Aggressive or overly playful behavior

How Do Shock Collars Work? 

By delivering small electric pulses, noticeable vibrations, or loud beeping sounds, shock collars provide an aversive message that discourages bad behavior. This alert offers irritation or annoyance to your pup, teaching them that obedience will allow them to avoid it in the future.

Much like using treats to encourage sitting, lying down, or other tricks, shock collars work to discourage undesirable behavior. It works in the same way, providing excellent results for even the most notoriously challenging dog breeds.

Why Are Shock Collars So Controversial?

Since the 1960s, our approach to animal rights has come a long way. People are becoming more and more concerned with the way we treat our pets, and rightly so. Dogs are the best animals on the planet, so why wouldn’t we want to look after them in the best way possible?

Those who say shock collars are inhumane will cite a few reasons in their case. Those arguments are as follows:

  • Shock collars are painful and make dogs feel uncomfortable
  • Positive reinforcement is just as effective, so shock collars are obsolete
  • Shock collars train our dogs to fear us, leading to a strained relationship

Shock Collars ARE Humane. Here’s Why.. 

The name ‘shock collar’ can be quite deceiving, often leading to confusion about these innovative devices. Dog training collars ARE humane and deliver the most effective results, especially when teaching difficult dogs.

Let’s dispel some of the myths and misconceptions.

Shock Collars Don’t Cause Pain

While delivering an electric shock to your dog may seem extreme, it doesn’t actually cause physical pain. Discomfort? Yes. Annoyance? Yes. Irritation? Yes.

One of the most effective ways to realize this is to try it out for yourself. Many dog owners have experimented with shock training collars, suggesting that the lowest levels can feel like an insect crawling on the skin or the vibration of a smartwatch.

There is No Lasting Damage

Another critical argument from animal rights advocates is that shock collars cause lasting physical and psychological damage. While the reason for using a training collar should be carefully considered, there is no solid evidence to suggest that they cause long-term harm. 

In modern shock training collars, the electrical pulses delivered to hounds are minimal. Strong enough to cause irritation but not powerful enough to cause pain, they offer momentary discomfort for a lifetime of obedience. Pet Supply Co. collars provide 16 levels of electric messaging, and even their biggest shock is capped at a mild level.

Your Relationship With Your Dog Will Improve

Dog training can be emotional for owners, often leading to frustration or unnecessary anger. This can cause them to shout at their pets in moments of hardship, avoid them altogether, or even return them to the shelter.

A shock collar provides a fast and effective solution, avoiding any emotional strain for both the owner and the dog. Instead of spending hours trying to make positive reinforcements work, these innovative devices can deliver a quick message to pups behaving badly.

Shock Training Collars Can Keep Your Dog From Harm

While activists will argue that shock collars bring dogs unnecessary discomfort, we believe that the training they experience can prevent potential harm in the future.

Aggressive or uncontrollable dogs can often get themselves into difficult situations, including:

  • Running into roads or dangerous environments
  • Fighting with other animals, leading to serious injury
  • Attacking humans, leading to potential legal action
  • Getting lost in the wild as a result of a failed recall

While a shock collar does inflict some momentary discomfort, the benefits of this completely outweigh the list of possible scenarios a dog could face. With effective obedience training, they can live a happy life without putting themselves at risk.

So, that’s the end of our argument explaining why shock collars ARE humane. They don’t cause pain, the irritation doesn’t last, and the benefits really do outweigh the negatives. It’s also important to mention that positive reinforcement training isn’t always a practical solution, particularly for older dogs or rescues with destructive habits.

If you’re looking for a humane dog training collar that works, visit the Pet Supply Co. website today. We sell a range of weatherproof and remote collars, ideal for kickstarting your dog training journey.